WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

sweendog · Post by **sweendog** » Wed Aug 25, 2010 1:01 pm

sean mcivor will get top 5

King · Post by **King** » Wed Aug 25, 2010 1:53 pm

1983 wrote:T. Harman in top 10. Killed it in Country Champs and every Satdy that he plays

Was very good against us last Saturday but if he received votes probably only one. That maybe his year's story. Deserving but mostly in losing teams and therefore not getting the threes.

asert · Post by **asert** » Wed Aug 25, 2010 2:30 pm

sweendog wrote:sean mcivor will get top 5

Who.... Surely if he is going to be a possible mail medallist he would be close to a household name.

King · Post by **King** » Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:17 pm

sweendog wrote:sean mcivor will get top 5

If you can rely on the Sunday Mail best players he will certainly win Christies B & F. Reckon there hasn't been a week he has missed best players.

mirror#3 · Post by **mirror#3** » Wed Aug 25, 2010 4:29 pm

King wrote:
sweendog wrote:sean mcivor will get top 5

If you can rely on the Sunday Mail best players he will certainly win Christies B & F. Reckon there hasn't been a week he has missed best players.

Sean has been in the best 15 out of 18 times, not a bad effort! But I agree with Asert, to get enough votes to win a Mail Medal you have to be a household name...... as per below.......
2009
S. Guilhaus
Morphettville Park
2008
T. Johnstone
Brighton D & OS
2007
J. Pomeroy
Happy Valley
2006
A. Bachmann
Christies Beach
2005
S. Middleton
Reynella
2004
S. Prescott
Reynella

The Note Book · Post by **The Note Book** » Wed Aug 25, 2010 5:17 pm

mirror#3 wrote:
King wrote:
sweendog wrote:sean mcivor will get top 5

If you can rely on the Sunday Mail best players he will certainly win Christies B & F. Reckon there hasn't been a week he has missed best players.

Sean has been in the best 15 out of 18 times, not a bad effort! But I agree with Asert, to get enough votes to win a Mail Medal you have to be a household name...... as per below.......
2009
S. Guilhaus
Morphettville Park
2008
T. Johnstone
Brighton D & OS
2007
J. Pomeroy
Happy Valley
2006
A. Bachmann
Christies Beach
2005
S. Middleton
Reynella
2004
S. Prescott
Reynella

What do you expect when it is umpires that do the votes...trying to umpire the game, remember who played well & who didn't, too much for them to comprehend one would think.

this sort of debate always raises the question of having an independent monitor of the game to determine who is actually best on ground, not just someone who the umpires remember...

asert · Post by **asert** » Wed Aug 25, 2010 5:36 pm

mirror#3 wrote:
King wrote:
sweendog wrote:sean mcivor will get top 5

If you can rely on the Sunday Mail best players he will certainly win Christies B & F. Reckon there hasn't been a week he has missed best players.

Sean has been in the best 15 out of 18 times, not a bad effort! But I agree with Asert, to get enough votes to win a Mail Medal you have to be a household name...... as per below.......
2009
S. Guilhaus
Morphettville Park
2008
T. Johnstone
Brighton D & OS
2007
J. Pome
Happy Valley
2006
A. Bachmann
Christies Beach
2005
S. Middleton
Reynella
2004
S. Prescott
Reynella

Exactly right. Unlike in afl familiar faces help greatly in this. As well as he may have played it would be unlikely. Plus will only poll 1 votes as Christies didn't win enough games for him.

Down the Hill · Post by **Down the Hill** » Wed Aug 25, 2010 5:46 pm

Seb Guilhaus was hardly a household name at least to SFL umpires and Wade from Marion likewise, and he polled enough votes last year to win the medal in most other years. Both played in sides that won less than half their games so if McIvor is as good as people are saying then he is still a chance.

Having said that, a certain no. 2 for the Brighton Bombers may be standing in his way.

risetothetop · Post by **risetothetop** » Thu Aug 26, 2010 11:42 am

Is Mcivor the lad that kicked out of fullback for them? if so he kicked a few massive torpedo's against brighton this year! Fabian must have showed him that from when he used to play!!!!

Bag The Points · Post by **Bag The Points** » Thu Aug 26, 2010 12:01 pm

risetothetop wrote:Is Mcivor the lad that kicked out of fullback for them? if so he kicked a few massive torpedo's against brighton this year! Fabian must have showed him that from when he used to play!!!!

powerful on-baller who wears no.10

ol man emu · Post by **ol man emu** » Tue Aug 31, 2010 9:01 pm

Liam Green, That boy can play.

King · Post by **King** » Wed Sep 01, 2010 4:33 pm

2010 Mail Medal top vote getters just announced. Winner to be crowned next Monday 13/9/10

A Grade top 5

Brad Hunter Bombers
Sean McIvor Christies
Josh Vick Cobras
Darren Marks Vikings
Chris Minns Shoes

Some surprises I guess, more so for who is not there.

King · Post by **King** » Wed Sep 01, 2010 4:51 pm

sweendog wrote:sean mcivor will get top 5

Well done sweendog! Give the man a cigar!

mirror#3 · Post by **mirror#3** » Wed Sep 01, 2010 7:06 pm

King wrote:rad Hunter Bombers
Sean McIvor Christies

4 out of 5 of these guys were rated quite highly in their own club best players, except Brad Hunter??? Only in club best players 4 times...

King · Post by **King** » Wed Sep 01, 2010 7:34 pm

mirror#3 wrote:
King wrote:rad Hunter Bombers
Sean McIvor Christies

4 out of 5 of these guys were rated quite highly in their own club best players, except Brad Hunter??? Only in club best players 4 times...

Would like to see him win it, if only to dispel the theory that you need to be a "household" name to win.

King · Post by **King** » Wed Sep 01, 2010 7:41 pm

Just for interest the B grade top 6 are;

Dale Anderson Aldinga
John McPherson Brighton
Wil Michalanney Brighton
Michael Hoffman Emus
Justin Finlay Shoes
Brian Cooper 'Flies

reppoh_eht · Post by **reppoh_eht** » Wed Sep 01, 2010 8:03 pm

King wrote:
mirror#3 wrote:
King wrote:rad Hunter Bombers
Sean McIvor Christies

4 out of 5 of these guys were rated quite highly in their own club best players, except Brad Hunter??? Only in club best players 4 times...

Would like to see him win it, if only to dispel the theory that you need to be a "household" name to win.

Correct me if I am wrong Brighton people, but isn't Brad Hunter a former League/Reserves player with South Adelaide?

Reckon he is more of a 'household' name than the others in that list (excluding Vick ofcourse)...

White Line Fever · Post by **White Line Fever** » Wed Sep 01, 2010 8:17 pm

reppoh_eht wrote:
King wrote:
mirror#3 wrote:
King wrote:rad Hunter Bombers
Sean McIvor Christies

4 out of 5 of these guys were rated quite highly in their own club best players, except Brad Hunter??? Only in club best players 4 times...

Would like to see him win it, if only to dispel the theory that you need to be a "household" name to win.

Correct me if I am wrong Brighton people, but isn't Brad Hunter a former League/Reserves player with South Adelaide?

Reckon he is more of a 'household' name than the others in that list (excluding Vick ofcourse)...

I'd rate Hunter in that list as winner.

t express · Post by **t express** » Wed Sep 01, 2010 8:21 pm

If Brad Hunter Wins A MAIL MEDAL.I will Hang Myself :Hangman:

LaughingKookaburra · Post by **LaughingKookaburra** » Wed Sep 01, 2010 9:41 pm

Watched Valleys v Towns on Sunday. I'm sure he is far from it (Best player in the SFL) but Ben Squire ripped Towns a new a--- hole and absolutely never looked like dropping anything nor missing a goal. Very impressive performance....

WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Re: WHO IS THE BEST PLAYER IN THE SFL

Who is online